I was always fascinated with the power of placebo, some organization conduct a clinical trial and 25 % respond to the drug and 20 % respond to the sugar pill, wow is human mind that effective? tons of products advertising in TV, radio, and news paper that we know it does not work but there are people who swear by it. People who believe in science "like me" usually find it hard to recommend it or approve the use of medications or procedure that we know it does not work, but I do not know if this the right approach. Glucosamine and chondrointin products have been shown to be as effective as placebo, so Is it a waste of money? NO it give hope, it give the placebo relief, and there may be small group that actually benefit clinical trial is not big enough or design to identify. A relative of mine called me from Egypt asking to send him one of these Glucosamine and chondrointin product that was recommended by a friend of his for his bad arthritis pain, I responded with my scientific reasoning that do not waste your money find a physician get real treatment or get a similar cheaper product from Egypt. Did I do the right thing? NO this person had so much hope and belief that this product coming from America would help him that it would actually helped him. He was so disappointed and so sad that I felt too much guilt for telling him the what I believed to be the truth. of course this lead to another philosophical question how to define truth? who should have the authority to not to tell other to stop having hope?
Here is why I think patient should use placebo or said different alternative and complementary medicine:
1) Placebo does work indicating the power of the human cerebral cortex and its control over our body specially pain perception.
2) Placebo is generally safe, you can not get side effect from nothing. This statement is not absolute, some natural product have their harms, and education about it is a key.
3) So if placebo work without side effect and is usually cheaper that other alternative why not recommended for everybody?
4) But would not selling placebo would be fraud, may be; But human have always accepted selling hope, yet ethically this had to explained to the patient in a way that maintain the hope effect with proving the fact that there no guarantee to work if it work for you use it if not stop wasting money. Information should be provide to the patient and if more beneficial treatment exist it should be recommended.
Are we as a human being need to deceived? Can not we unlock our brain power to control our life, our pain, our anxiety without a magic pill that do it for us? may be we can, may be we cannot, may be that is limitation in how we function, may we are unaware that we can do it.
No comments:
Post a Comment